More Rotten Fruit of Vatican II: Franciscans Abandon Phoenix Basilica

“It is with heavy hearts that the Franciscan Friars withdraw from St. Mary’s Basilica. Stay with us throughout the year as we celebrate our Franciscan legacy. In the words of Pope Francis (sic), “Let the Church always be a place of mercy and hope, where everyone is welcomed, loved and forgiven.” May that be our promise to each other in the coming year.”

This is stunning. The Franciscan Friars of Santa Barbara have run this parish since 1895. It sounds like their dwindling numbers have led to a nationwide restructuring, and this place had to be sacrificed. Wow.

And they were “reverent” Novus Ordo, too: Chant, traditional organ, Gloria, Sanctus, Agnus Dei all in Latin. But the preaching was SJW all the way.

The Basilica itself was Consecrated in 1915; it is quite beautiful and was never wreckovated. It is smack downtown, on the same campus as the diocesan offices. It’s the only Basilica in Arizona.

Statement from the Diocese of Phoenix regarding Saint Mary’s Basilica and the Franciscan Friars of the Santa Barbara Province

The Franciscan Friars of the Santa Barbara Province have informed the Diocese of Phoenix that because of diminished priestly vocations and a restructuring of their United States Provinces, they will withdraw from pastoral leadership of Saint Mary’s Basilica in downtown Phoenix. This decision was part of a long discernment process by the Franciscans, that will include other changes in assignments across their six U.S. provinces.

The Franciscan Friars have served the parish of Saint Mary’s since 1895 – 127 years of founding parishes and missions throughout Maricopa County. St. Mary’s Food Bank, St. Vincent de Paul and St. Mary’s High School were all founded under their leadership. On behalf of the faithful of the Diocese of Phoenix, Bishop John P. Dolan, expresses his deep gratitude to the Franciscans for their dedication and commitment to this historical first parish in Phoenix. In the Franciscan spirit they have ministered with generosity and compassion, playing a significant role in the growth and formation of the Catholic community over the past 127 years. 

The Franciscans Friars will maintain their presence at the Franciscan Renewal Center, the Casa – Our Lady of the Angels Church in Paradise Valley and the Old Mission San Xavier del Bac outside of Tucson. The plan is for Saint Mary’s Basilica parish to be returned to the Diocese in the Summer of 2023. Future staffing is yet to be determined by the Diocese of Phoenix. The Franciscan Friars and the Diocese of Phoenix are committed to cooperation during this time of transition. A series of events are being planned to celebrate and mark the significant impact of the Basilica’s history in the Diocese of Phoenix. In a special way we keep Fr. Michael Weldon, OFM, the friars of Saint Mary’s, the staff, and parishioners in our prayer. We are grateful for their pastoral care of the people of God and for the diligent oversight of this historic place of prayer. May Our Lady and Saint Francis of Assisi pray and guide us in the days ahead.

12 thoughts on “More Rotten Fruit of Vatican II: Franciscans Abandon Phoenix Basilica”

  1. Is it permitted to speculate that since these Franciscans seem somewhat conservative, they have decided to abandon Phoenix in view of your new bishop? Since their numbers are down, why waste good priests in a battle with a goofy bishop?

  2. Beautiful church and I hope the new bishop won’t let it go to rot. If it isn’t already, it should be presented for historical site designation. That helps sometimes ward off demolition or modernization, but not always. And now for something sobering… when you look at the enrollment at novus ordo diocesan seminaries and novus ordo seminaries for orders like the Franciscans, versus the number of priests age 70 and up, it’s not sustainable.

  3. Not surprising to anyone who has taken an honest look at the statistics of Catholics in America and the West in general.
    The Baby-boomers are dying off, and Gen-Xers, and Millennials aren’t replacing them. We’re now falling off a “demographic cliff” that people have warned was coming for longer than the last decade.
    More and more Churches are going to close and fall into ruin in the coming years. It will be because there just won’t be any Catholics to fill the pews.

  4. Remember that monasteries were NOT subject to the local bishop prior to “St.” Benedict’s reforms. His job was to subjugate montasteries to the secular bishops. Instead of abandoning the cathedral they should have recalled this and defied the bishop. Monks should never be subject to the secular bishops. That’s like a man being subject to his wife. Its unnatural. Worse its like a man being subject to a husband. Completely insane.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.