
It seems we mostly are choosing to ignore that Robert Westman, the young man who shot up a Catholic Church filled with children, drew a picture of a demon staring back at him in the mirror. Why? Because believing there’s more to the world than the physical realm, calls us to be more. And for some, that’s scarier than anything else.
So it’s being largely ignored.

We’ve dismissed it. The whole lot. With a wave of the hand. With a shrug. We call it “the Enlightenment.” It’s a flat world without shadows. A world without evil. Just… bad behavior. Bad parenting. Social ills. We dissect it. We diagnose it. We give it a name and a pill to remedy it. We make it small.
But look around. The facts. The hard, cold facts. The sheer, unmitigated evil that walks among us. Not the guy stealing bread but the cruelty that has no motive. The malice that defies explanation. The smile at other people’s pain. The senseless horror that slips the mask. The kind of evil that makes you want to lock your doors and look at the sky. What do you call that? ‘Complex socioeconomic factors’? ‘Psychological deviance’?
You call it what you want. Put it in a box and tie a ribbon around it. But the stain remains. It’s a tear in the fabric. A hole in the reality you’ve so carefully constructed. Because you’ve explained everything, right? The light. The sun. The stars. You’ve charted it all. But you can’t chart this. This… blackness. This thing that looks at us and hates us.
But you can’t see the shadow because if you admit the shadow, you must admit the light. We’re so eager to deny the demons. Why? Because then we can deny the angels. Angels have consequences. Love, salvation, faith, grace. These all have consequences that quarks, atoms, and leptons don’t. You can believe in them without changing your life. Without changing yourself. But love calls us out of ourselves, asks us to be loving and faithful. Love asks us to pick up our cross. So you can laugh it all off as myth. I get it. If you admit there’s more then you might have to be more.
So go ahead. Stick to your facts. Cling to your materialism. Call it science. Call it progress. But when you look into the eyes of true evil—the kind that makes the blood run cold—you’ll see something that doesn’t fit your spreadsheets. Something that can’t be explained away. And in that moment, in that sickening, soul-shaking instant, you might just find yourself looking at darkness so black you’ll pray for light. I pray that you’ll find it.
The division is between those who will acknowledge Westman’s motive and those who won’t.
Of those who will ackowledge it: Everyone, EVERYONE, has spread that exact devil-mirror picture and, thankfully, said we’re in a spiritual war.
This was a horrible tragedy but for the argument of this post you’ve got prominent high profile people who promote the Latin Mass doing wacky far left esoteric stuff like Peter Kwasniewski and Joseph Shaw, blending that with Traditional Catholism. Their argument is that yes people are too overly rational and influenced by the enlightenedment.
What wacky far left esoteric stuff are you referring to?
The fact is that Satan is extremely smart.
For example, many of the celebrity exorcists we see are controlled by demons. Father Ripperger of “lesser of 2 evils” fame is a prime example.
Ripperger casually makes up the names of demons, makes fantastic claims, all for fame. What priest, much less an exorcist, would encourage supporting any evil?
If our clergy doesn’t take demons and evil seriously, and ofc this is a fruit of Vatican 2, most of the laity won’t. And what better way to compromise things than to have false exorcists leading the charge?
Obviously the shooter here had problems and then through his own free will or weakness became possessed, became evil. Did evil acts.
I will also say if this was a Synagogue that was shot up the nation would still be in mourning.
Mike – There you go again, with your anti-Ripperger fetish. Are you ordained? Do you rebuke & cast out demons in frequent exorcisms? If not, then you wouldn’t know what he knows.
James Martin is ordained. Pope Paul VI was ordained. Martin Luther was ordained. Judas Iscariot was ordained.
It’s rank desperation to appeal to authority. I am as qualified to critique Ripperger as you are to defend him. The difference is that I am correct.
You can find plenty of errors of Ripperger if you wanted. We can start with this absolute truth: no exorcist should recommend choosing evil. Which is what this man did.
Mike – You literally just compared Father Ripperger to Judas Iscariot & James Martin.
That, in itself, disqualifies your criticisms.
P.S. To be sure, anybody is entitled to their opinion on anything.
And yet, it remains true at the same time, that some opinions self-evidently make far, far less sense than other opinions.
P.P.S. And the Magisterium & Deposit of Faith do arguments from authority, Mike. The Church, in which it appears you are not ordained, is an authority structure. It’s OK.
Demons, which apparently you do not cast out of people in exorcisms (as Jesus Christ does, via Father Ripperger’s invocations), obey Christ’s authority and respond to his (or Father Ripperger’s) arguments from authority. It’s OK.
P.P.P.S. Biden forced The Jab on people. And pushed abortion. “Most evil President” at least in living memory -> Biden. and Mike you will never, NEVER be able to talk your way around that.
Hang on a minute…..OK just prayed for you buddy. God bless you!
If Father Ripperger excuses evil, why isn’t he like Judas or Luther?
Buddy are you actually Father Ripperger?
Lots of words and you still can’t explain his errors away.
Do you know Ripperger has a school/academy that trains exorcists? He has gotten in trouble in Ohio for his actions.
But whatever justifies voting for Trump I guess.
Your essay could be a very solid review of the doctor character in ‘Nefarious’.
Great movie….Screwtape enters the 21st century. Think I’ll watch it again tonight…thanks for the prod.
Mike, hanging a dog because it barked too much is evil. Sodomizing a toddler until he dies is orders of magnitude more evil.
Martha,
Do you think, then, that a priest should tell you to hang dogs then? Or would a priest tell you to refrain from both?
Why would a priest tell you to support hanging dogs in this case unless he was immoral or compromised in some way himself?
Note, when Jesus told Pilate he had the lesser sin over the Jews for His imprisonment and execution he didn’t become a pagan Roman citizen, he didn’t let Pilate off the hook. Pilate still killed Him. Pilate still did evil.
You ok with that? You ok with how lesser evil Trump has pushed our country into the abyss?
What a terrible thing to see people rationalize evil.
Three years ago when I started going to the TLM I thought my days of sitting side by side in the pew with pro-abortion minded leftists – voting for abortion by voting for Democrats (Biden in particular) – was over. Naively I thought TLM people were more conservative-minded, even liking President Trump, and that they would not be Hamas supporters, and so on. Little did I know, but am fast finding out, how wrong I was. I find myself more alone now than when I went to the NO. Perhaps I need to go back to the Vatican II Church. At least I had friends there.
Susan, I encourage you to stick with the TLM. The old Mass is much better. There will always be sinners in the Church. Pray for them and stay confessed.
Um I think the pandemic of arms and global weather are what we should be focused on. Like brother Leo.